This episode of "Amusing Minds with Ben and Rodney" features guest Jashin Lin, diving deep into the fascinating worlds of fan fiction and head canon. The discussion defines fan fiction as creative works written by fans, tracing its modern origins back to the 1960s and 70s with the burgeoning Star Trek fandom. It’s categorized broadly as "transformative fan works," which encompass various forms like fan videos, filks, and fan art that expand upon or reinterpret existing creative material. Head canon, on the other hand, is presented as a more personal extension of fan theories, where individuals internally regard certain ideas or interpretations as true within a fictional universe, even if they lack official validation.
The hosts and Jashin share their personal connections to this creative sphere. Ben expresses his fascination with how fans craft their own versions of established fictional universes, while Rodney, though less experienced with reading fan fiction, enjoys theorizing, drawing parallels to popular "who would win in a fight" scenarios. Jashin's personal journey into fan fiction began in seventh grade around 1999-2000, introduced by a friend who was deeply immersed in Sailor Moon fan fiction. For her, it served as a vital escape and a source of intellectual stimulation, aligning perfectly with her inherent love for reading and writing. The conversation also highlights how fan fiction has evolved into a "remix culture," continually reinterpreting existing material, and its significant role as a launchpad for aspiring writers, offering immediate feedback and a platform to refine their craft, as evidenced by authors like Naomi Novik and John Scalzi who began their careers in fan fiction.
The episode further explores the delicate balance between fan theories and official canon. Ben appreciates fan theories that enrich existing narratives or resolve unresolved questions, citing the Captain America/Natasha fan theory as an example. However, Rodney expresses concern that overly invested fan theories can lead to disappointment if official releases fail to meet fan expectations, a sentiment Jashin echoes, noting how some fans declare their "childhoods ruined" when new content contradicts their speculations. The discussion also touches upon the intellectual property aspect, noting that copyright is a relatively modern concept compared to centuries of human storytelling. Jashin points out that J.K. Rowling was an early advocate for fandom, encouraging fan fiction writers rather than viewing them as copyright infringers. The episode also covers the unwritten rule that fan fiction writers generally should not profit from their work to avoid legal issues, and the dual nature of fan communities, offering both supportive spaces and the potential for toxicity. Jashin recommends Archive of Our Own (AO3) and Fanlore.org as excellent resources for exploring fan fiction and fandom history.
No comments:
Post a Comment